So the Giants are on the doorstep of shattering all of our hopes and dreams for a repeat. Die hard baseball fans will still watch baseball, but it’s always better when you have a team or a couple of teams to root for. There are some important protocols and criteria for choosing your “adopted” baseball squad. Choose carefully. If you pull for a wrong team, you could be guilty of baseball blasphemy.
First lets discuss the rules. They are very simple rules.
- They can’t be the Dodgers. (That is easy. LA sucks and won’t make the playoffs ever again).
- They can’t be the Braves. I’ll explain a little more later, but seriously, does anyone question this rule?
- The team must possess minimal former Dodgers. (Former Giants are a bonus but not essential).
- The team must not have beat us (Giants) in any critical postseason events.
We will start here because this one is easy. On the surface, the novice fan may want to root for the D-backs because if they win it all, we automatically get second. That is a faulty amateur theory. Let’s dive in. Look at the manager of the team. Kirk Gibson is the skipper and that immediately eliminates the team from our rooting choices. Nobody wants a postseason filled with highlights of a gimpy, former Dodger Kirk rounding the bases, rockin’ a pathetic mustache and Jack Buck complaining how he can’t believe what he just saw. Get some glasses Jack. It’s a home run. I believed it, I just hated it granted I was 8). Rule 4 is safe and in addition, Arizona isn’t a great rival of ours even though if they play in our division. They only have 2 former Dodgers, but they are eliminated by their manager. They could be in the running if they would fire Gibby and hire third base coach Matt Williams. Oh yes, I said Matt Williams. Breathe in the nostalgia.
Another easy decision. Ok seriously, in the National League, the Braves fall a very close second to the Dodgers in the hate category. Do you really want to watch a postseason with that stupid tomahawk chant? Nope. But let’s talk about the rules.Obviously, they violate rule 2. Amazingly enough, the Braves have never knocked the Giants out of the post-season. That is, in part, because the Giants didn’t make the postseason a whole lot in the 90’s. In addition, in 2002 and 2010, the Giants had to go through the Braves to get to the World Series and the Braves rolled over like well-trained poodles (and we are grateful). So why the hate? Did I mention the chant? Or the fans. Second worst fans in all of baseball. (Seriously who would willingly DO that chant?) I guess the rest of us got sick of them in the 90’s and the rest is just a bad hangover. The only thing the Braves have going for them is that they aren’t the Dodgers. The Braves have a decent Dodger ratio with 3 players being former Dodgers. Not bad, but rule 2 is in effect. It’s the rules… it’s science.
Ok this is another tricky one. The Brewers are always terrible and who doesn’t love a good underdog story. Next year, they will probably break apart the team so this is pretty much their shot. Let’s break it down by the rules. Rule 1 and 2 are off to a tremendous start. They aren’t the Dodgers and they aren’t the Braves. Fab! They have 3 former Dodgers on the team which isn’t bad. But they have K-Rod. Ok, so this is a tricky part to rule 4. Technically the Brewers never beat the Giants….But K-Rod did….In the freakin World Series. Ask yourself this: if he were to play in a game you were watching, how would you deal with the emotional trauma you are bound to encounter. Are you ready to deal with that? I’m not. Especially with the way this season is ending, I need happy thoughts. K-Rod brings back angry thoughts… sad thoughts. It wouldn’t be baseball blasphemy to pick the Brewers, but I just can’t do it.
Philly is my pick for the National League. They satisfy all of the rules. I am not usually a Philly fan. In fact, I have never pulled for them in a post-season. However, they satisfy rule 1 and 2. They have 2 players that are former Dodgers which is better than all the other teams that are in. Yes, Charlie Manuel played for the Dodgers but he wasn’t that great. He definitely never made it to the infamous status of Kirk Gibson. Therefore, they are a much better pick than Arizona when it comes down to rule 3. Rule 4 should be a tie because no team has really kicked us out of too many playoff games. However, I prefer the Phillies for this rule because last year we beat them to win the NL. This year, we will be sitting in our libraries that smell of rich mahogany, drinking our finest scotch, smoking our best pipes, and we can confidently say “They aren’t that good, we owned those guys last year.”
Can’t root for the Phillies personally. The Yankees of the NL. Go Brewers (all about the beer).
I’ve lost all respect for you Stover. The Phillies? Shane “Weasel Face” Victorinto? Disagree. Go Brewers, Go Braves. (Seriously, who hates the Braves?)
Good write up but, NO WAY can I pull for the Phillies! The WORST fans in MLB. Example: fan interference in Florida Marlins game last week. Brewers, NOT! The Tony Plush thang & FATASS Fielder with that walk-off, falling bowling pin thing that Craig Counsell came up with vs the Giants in Milwaukee last year. Dirtbags(AZ) for all your mentioned reasons above. Personally, I gotta go with the Braves for 2 reasons. Yeah,your right about the Tomahawk chop(HATE THAT CRAP!) but, I want to see Chipper Jones get to the WS and maybe win one for Bobby Cox.
How can anyone go for Atlanta? They named themselves America’s team. arrogance. They are the Yankees of the nl imo. I’m not a huge Phillies fan either, but I’m pulling for them this year. But I’ll give you that their fans are super annoying.
any Giants fan old enough to remember 1993 will never root for the braves.
Amen to your last point, Bout. NEVER root for the ^%&ing, Braves.
But let’s get back to the important stuff. That was some of the finest baseball writing I have ever had the opportunity to run my eyes across. I giggled, laughed (out loud…by myself) and was nearly brought to tears, both for purposes of nostalgia and painful reflection.
Well done, sir. Well done.